Civic Witness Series - Questions from the Attic

How do we explain democratic norms?

Civic Witness Series: Questions from the Attic, is founded on a simple premise: the people living through democratic erosion have questions the ‘experts’ aren’t addressing; it is inspired by and in honor of Adia in the Attic. Those questions matter because they provide an opportunity for sharing and documenting what democratic erosion feels like to people living through it. We don’t pretend to have “The Answer” to these questions, but we hope to stimulate the conversation her questions have prompted.

Democracy’s Unwritten Rules: Why Norms Matter More Than We Think

Most Americans understand that our democracy rests on the Constitution, the rule of law, free elections and the separation of powers. These are the formal structures of our republic. We learn about them in school, celebrate them on national holidays and assume they will always be there.

But there is another foundation of American democracy that receives considerably less attention: the unwritten rules that govern how those institutions are supposed to function. We call them democratic norms. And one of the most troubling developments in our politics today is how quickly we are discovering just how fragile they really are.

Norms are not laws. There is no constitutional provision requiring a president to respect the independence of the Justice Department, refrain from attacking judges who rule against him, or avoid using public office for personal financial gain. There is no statute requiring a president to tell the truth, respect political opponents or recognize that the office he occupies belongs to the country rather than him personally.

Yet these expectations have helped sustain American democracy for generations. They are the informal agreements that make the formal system work.

The rules that aren’t written down

Think about it this way. The Constitution establishes the rules, but norms provide the restraint that prevents those rules from being manipulated beyond recognition.

A good example is the peaceful transfer of presidential power. The Constitution establishes how a new president takes office, but it cannot compel a defeated president to accept the results of an election, acknowledge the legitimacy of a successor or cooperate in the transition. Those things depend on an unwritten understanding that the country and its democratic institutions are more important than any individual’s political fortunes.

Political scientists Steven Levitsky and Daniel Ziblatt, in their book How Democracies Die, identify two particularly important norms: mutual toleration and institutional forbearance. Mutual toleration means accepting political opponents as legitimate participants in the democratic process, even if we disagree with them. Institutional forbearance means exercising restraint in the use of political power, recognizing that the ability to do something does not necessarily mean one should.

These ideas may sound almost quaint in today’s political environment. But they are essential. Democracy cannot function if every election becomes an existential struggle, every political opponent is treated as an enemy, and every available government power becomes a weapon to be used against those who disagree.

When breaking the rules becomes the “new norm”

The danger of democratic norms is that they are fragile precisely because they are unwritten. They depend on people respecting them, and on institutions and the public holding those who violate them accountable.

Once political leaders discover that they can use government institutions for partisan purposes without meaningful consequences, the incentive to exercise restraint diminishes. Once the public becomes accustomed to behavior that would previously have been considered disqualifying, the boundaries of acceptable conduct begin to shift.

This is how democratic erosion happens. Rarely does a democracy disappear overnight. More often, its institutions remain standing while the traditions and expectations that give them meaning are gradually hollowed out.

Congress must be willing to exercise oversight. Courts must be able to make decisions without intimidation. Government agencies must be able to perform their duties without being reduced to instruments of personal or partisan loyalty. The press must be free to scrutinize those in power. And citizens must be able to disagree without being treated as enemies. These are not partisan expectations. They are the foundations of a functioning republic.

Democracy is not self-sustaining

Democratic norms are much like the foundation of a house. When they are intact, we rarely think about them. We notice the walls, the windows and the roof. But when the foundation begins to crack, the entire structure is at risk. We have spent generations assuming that our democratic traditions were permanent features of American life. They are not. They survive only when political leaders, institutions and citizens insist that certain boundaries must not be crossed, regardless of who holds power.

The question we should be asking ourselves is not simply whether our democracy can survive Donald Trump. It is whether we will still recognize the democracy we have known when he is gone. The Constitution may remain intact. Elections may continue to take place. Congress and the courts may still function. But if we lose the shared understanding that power must be exercised with restraint, that political opponents are not enemies, and that no president is above the institutions he or she serves, we will have lost something fundamental.

Democracy doesn’t die only when someone breaks the law. Sometimes it dies when everyone becomes accustomed to behavior that once would have been unthinkable. And by the time we recognize what we have lost, rebuilding it may be much harder than we ever imagined.

Bruce Berton

Bruce Berton served as a U.S. diplomat for over three decades, ultimately rising to the senior ranks of the Foreign Service, including two years as Ambassador and Head of Mission at the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe’s (OSCE) Mission to Bosnia and Herzegovina. He is a Pacific Northwest native and a graduate of Pacific Lutheran University. He is a member of The Steady State.

Next
Next

An Unknown Soldier. An All-Too-Known Disgrace.